Court dismisses case on Holyrood’s second independence referendum powers

Scotland’s supreme civil court has dismissed a case questioning whether an independence referendum could be held without Westminster’s consent – saying it was ‘hypothetical, academic and premature’.

Martin Keatings brought the case to Scotland’s Court of Session on behalf of pro-independence group Forward As One, ahead of Holyrood’s election in May. 

A two-day hearing last month heard from Aidan O’Neill, who was acting on behalf of Mr Keatings. He argued that voters needed to know if such action is possible.   

Lady Carmichael has now dismissed the case, ruling it was ‘plainly raised prematurely’, with the question of another referendum ‘also hypothetical, and may never come to pass’.

Lady Carmichael has thrown out a case asking whether Holyrood had the power to legislate a second independence referendum, her decision said the case was 'hypothetical, academic and premature'

Lady Carmichael has thrown out a case asking whether Holyrood had the power to legislate a second independence referendum, her decision said the case was 'hypothetical, academic and premature'

Lady Carmichael has thrown out a case asking whether Holyrood had the power to legislate a second independence referendum, her decision said the case was ‘hypothetical, academic and premature’

In her decision published on Friday, she said: ‘The defenders’ submissions on these matters all express in slightly different ways the underlying proposition that it is either not necessary, or not possible, for the court to provide this pursuer with the remedy that he is seeking.

‘The action is for these reasons, hypothetical, academic and premature, and the pursuer lacks standing to bring it.

‘For the reasons given… I would have reached the same conclusion even if a draft Bill were available for consideration.’

Lady Carmichael added that the court would intervene if there was any future allegation that Holyrood had acted unlawfully by forcing through a referendum.

‘Having reached the view that I have in relation to standing, prematurity and the hypothetical nature of the proceedings, I do not require to determine whether to grant the declarators sought would have been incompatible with the separation of powers.

‘It is, however, important that matters which may properly be the subject of political debate and campaigning in the democratic process are permitted to unfold and be worked out in the political process, and that the courts intervene only when they need to do so to fulfil their function as guardians of the rule of law.

‘The courts will clearly intervene to determine allegations of unlawfulness.

‘Where, however, there is no allegation of unlawfulness, and the court is asked for a determination as to the state of the law in an area which is the subject of current political debate and controversy, it will be important to ensure that the question of whether an answer is required in order to protect the rule of law is addressed with rigour.’

The judge said it is ‘unnecessary and would be inappropriate for me to express an opinion on the question of law’ given the case was based on an ‘assumption that a referendum is to be conducted, or has actually already been conducted, under an Act of the Scottish Parliament’.

In addition, no view was taken on ‘the intentions of the Scottish Government’ in regards to any draft Bill.

She said both ‘the first defender and the pursuer to some extent asked me to speculate… that would not be determinative of whether there was an issue of law on which the pursuer was entitled to a ruling from the court’.

The case was brought on behalf of pro-independence group Forward As One, which argued voters needed to know what powers Scottish parliament has ahead of May's election. Pictured: Nicola Sturgeon addressing parliament last month

The case was brought on behalf of pro-independence group Forward As One, which argued voters needed to know what powers Scottish parliament has ahead of May's election. Pictured: Nicola Sturgeon addressing parliament last month

The case was brought on behalf of pro-independence group Forward As One, which argued voters needed to know what powers Scottish parliament has ahead of May’s election. Pictured: Nicola Sturgeon addressing parliament last month

On Mr Keatings’s standing, the judge said it is ‘relevant to note… the pursuer is an enfranchised voter in a system of representative democracy’.

While she said ‘he and every other voter has the right to vote for representatives in the Scottish Parliament’, she added ‘it is correct to say that Parliament derives its authority, strength and legitimacy from the electorate’.

Lady Carmichael concluded by highlighting that elected members are the ones ‘who then go on to make judgments, in their capacity as legislators’.

A legal opinion for Forward As One was first published by Mr O’Neill in December 2019, on the constitutionality of the issue after Prime Minister Boris Johnson refused to grant a section 30 order under the Act to pass laws normally reserved to Westminster.

One had been granted by the UK Government ahead of the 2014 independence referendum, in which Scotland voted to remain part of the UK by 55.3% to 44.7%. 

Mr Keatings is standing as an independent candidate for Mid-Scotland and Fife in the May 6 vote.

Link hienalouca.com

Advertising:

Tips to Find Low Priced Luxury Holiday Package Deals Fast

For most families, it has already been a common practice to spend the Holiday season in a foreign location. This is caused by the aviation market changes which have given a lot of benefits for people who travel a lot. Airfares going to different tourist destinations are becoming more inexpensive. What does this mean? If there is a perfect time to purchase luxury holiday package deals, now it the right time! Based on the market trend nowadays, you can save both money and time when you go for a luxury holiday. There are countless offers that combine travel and accommodation in one package which is a lot cheaper than getting separate deals. Aside from that, it is also risky to individually book the services that you need for the vacation. You might end up missing out on some important details of the trip. Unlike when you take advantage of luxury holiday package deals, you can be sure that everything is organized meticulously and according to what you really need. Nonetheless, you would still need to carefully select the package that would fit your needs. Review the following tips in getting packages that are reasonably priced. · Normally, luxury tour packages include accommodation, flight travel and transportation to individual tourist destinations. It would be best to choose the complete package so you won’t have to worry about other vacation elements. In addition to that, these are the packages that have the biggest discounts. · You can get big mark down prices, if you will purchase more packages. It is not a bad idea to share the wonderful moment with your loved ones. By doing so, you would not only enjoy, you will also save more money. You can even use your savings for other activities on your vacation. · It would be best to know how much you are willing to pay for the luxury tour packages. You can already work around your budget. You have to stick to your budget. If not, you might end up spending a lot and you will be left with less money for your vacation. · Prices may vary depending on the destination of the tour. You can do a research about places that are attractive yet inexpensive. There are thousands of destinations and you just have to choose wisely. · There are packages that include recreational activities. This means that you are paying for all the activities when you purchase these packages. The right thing to do is to make sure that the activities that are included would be the ones that you really enjoy. There is no sense in paying for activities that will not really make your vacation memorable. If you are going with friends, you should also consider their preferences so that you can be sure that everyone will enjoy the trip. There are other ways on how you can be sure that you are getting the best deal for your luxury holiday vacation. No matter how you choose to do it, you have to get adequate information about the packages. This will help you determine whether it is worth the price.

(Total views: 6 Time, 1 visits per day)

Leave a Reply