The Liverpool building firm hired to lead Unite’s £50million
Unite hired the Flanagan Group to head the construction of its multi-million pound Birmingham complex with work beginning in 2015.
In December, Liverpool Mayor Joe Anderson was arrested as part of Operation Aloft too.
How the asset-rich union came to give the contract to the family-run business over others starts with a ducks’-feet salesman turned project manager, an investigation by
Gerry White – who amassed enormous wealth from lobster trading and selling ducks’ feet to the Far East – set up Purple Apple Ltd in 2004.
The company became the property manager of the Transport and General Workers’ Union in 2005 before it merged with another union to become Unite two years later.
Last year, Liverpool Mayor Joe Anderson (pictured) was arrested as part of Operation Aloft – a 15-month investigation looking into agreements between property developers and the council
Gerry White (left) – who amassed enormous wealth from lobster trading and selling ducks’ feet to the Far East – set up Purple Apple Ltd in 2004. Len McCluskey (right) – a dock’s worker-turned unionist – took on the role of General Secretary of Unite in January 2011
The decision to appoint Purple Apple in the key role was not made by the TGWU’s then-leader Tony Woodley – who was according to The Times an ‘old acquaintance’ of Mr White – nor by any other member of its executive council alone, Unite claim.
Unite brought in Purple Apple Management, as project manager, and the Flanagan Group – lead by Paul Flanagan (pictured) – as its contractor on the £50million Birmingham project
Purple Apple instead had to do a presentation to the executive council – along with several other companies.
In 2008, Purple Apple was described as property manager for Unite publicly.
The Times claims Mr Woodley had lived for some time in a London flat in a building subsequently purchased by Mr White’s company.
It was in that year that Mr White died – aged just 64 – therefore ended Purple Apple’s relationship with Unite.
Mr White’s former-business partner Mike Ryder took over, forming a new company called Purple Apple Management Ltd.
Len McCluskey – a dock worker-turned unionist – took on the role of General Secretary of Unite in January 2011.
Unite announced plans for a new national training centre in Birmingham and in 2012, the cost of the project was expected to be around £7million and plans included a national conference centre, training and education facilities and a hotel.
But a deal fell through in November the following year – after a formal offer was made by the union.
Sources reportedly told The Times that Unite wanted to use Purple Apple Management – which had an average of four employees per year since 2010 – as its project manager, instead of the council’s own developer.
Unite were reportedly warned that Purple Apple Management did not have the necessary resources for a project of this size.
But the union disputes this, instead claiming the first site fell through because Unite would have to share ownership of the building once it is completed, claiming it would have been ‘a bad investment for the union’.
The Birmingham development’s estimated cost hit £35million by 2015 – and was reportedly £50million by December the following year. The project (pictured) was completed in 2020
A nearby alternative site was proposed and Unite brought in Purple Apple Management, as project manager, and the Flanagan Group – lead by Paul Flanagan – as its contractor.
The Flanagan group – which has also completed construction work for Unite in Swansea, Stoke and Liverpool after Mr McCluskey became general secretary – was appointed in the Birmingham project after a comprehensive tendering process, the union claims.
The company’s website contains a glowing testimonial attributed to Unite, in which the union apparently describes the Flanagan Group as ‘our go-to firm for the maintenance and modernisation of Unite premises across the UK’.
Mayor of Liverpool Joe Anderson (pictured) was sensationally arrested in December along with his son David
But Unite said it was false to suggest that ‘the Flanagan Group is somehow a preferred contractor’.
One of the other 40 sub-contractors on the Birmingham project was Safety Support Consultants – a Liverpool company headed by the son of the city’s mayor Joe Anderson.
David Anderson’s firm was brought in by Purple Apple to make sure the project complied with health and safety requirements.
The development’s estimated cost hit £35million by 2015 – and was reportedly £50million by December the following year. It was completed in 2020.
Mr Flanagan was arrested in September 2019 on suspicion of conspiracy to commit bribery as part of Operation Aloft – Merseyside police investigation into alleged fraudulent building contracts.
He has since been released and the Flanagan group is one of the Liverpool firms being investigated – along with several others.
Operation Aloft is not connected to the Unite contracts.
Mr Anderson was sensationally arrested in December along with his son David.
He was suspended from the
Mr Anderson – who maintains his innocence – announced later that month that he will taking ‘unpaid leave’ from his position while the investigation into him continues.
Derek Hatton – the former Trotskyist deputy leader of Liverpool City Council – was also arrested as part of the investigation and was held on suspicion of witness intimidation. All three have been released on bail
Derek Hatton – the former Trotskyist deputy leader of Liverpool City Council – was also arrested as part of the investigation and was held on suspicion of witness intimidation. All three have been released on bail.
Flanagan Group is one of several Liverpool construction companies being investigated under Operation Aloft.
No Unite contracts awarded to Flanagan Group – nor the one given to Safety Support Consultants by Purple Apple – is connected to the Operation Aloft investigation and there is no suggestion of any criminal wrongdoing in the union’s dealings with either company.
A Unite spokesperson told MailOnline: ‘The reports in The Times are an extremely crude attempt to smear Unite and its leadership through a disgraceful attempt at guilt-by-association.
‘They attempt to create an impression of a connection between Unite and the criminal investigations taking place in the City of Liverpool on the basis of what even the newspaper is forced to admit is no evidence whatsoever.
Mr Anderson (pictured) – who maintains his innocence – announced later that month that he will taking ‘unpaid leave’ from his position while the investigation into him continues
‘There is absolutely no link between the union or any of its officials with those investigations. Merely coming from Merseyside is not an offence.
‘The reports are riddled with inaccuracies concerning the construction of Unite’s education, hotel and office facility in Birmingham and they include figures that are wildly erroneous, presented without source or verification.
‘The facility in Birmingham also contains a 1000-capacity state of the art conference centre.
‘Independent auditors have confirmed that the hotel, education and conference centre is as an asset to the union to the value of the union’s investment.
‘At every stage of this project there have been clear and consistent tendering requirements, with progress reported regularly to the union’s Executive Council.
‘Unite’s Birmingham complex is a world-class facility, built to the highest standards using unionised workers and it will help to regenerate a derelict area of England’s second city.
‘Those who seek to misrepresent this project do so to advance their own agenda relating to the election for General Secretary which will take place this year. They have an established disregard for the truth.
‘Unite is focused solely on protecting its members during the current pandemic crisis.
‘It does so effectively because its financial strength and democratic governance is second to none in the trade union movement.’